View Single Post
Old 28-07-2007, 12:19 AM   #169 (permalink)
mollusc
Member
 
mollusc's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2006
Location: Poised expectantly over the inter-web.
Posts: 88
mollusc will become famous soon enough
Quote:
Originally Posted by Owen D View Post
Going to pick you up on this.
You say the crew panicked, it was not the weapon that was at fault.
The 57mm aka 6 pdr could take out a Tiger if hit in the right place.
Therefore not an example of ineffective weapon system but a poorly trained crew member.
... and I'll pick you up on this!
It's nothing to do with a poorly trained crew member old chap. Yes a 6pdr could take out a Tiger if hit in the right place...

That right place was in the side of the Tiger, at about 600 yards or less, and at angles of less than 30 degrees. So, in your opinion then, the properly trained crew member would have kindly asked the Tiger's crew to "come-about 300 yards away please and nicely side on, thankyou"?

In vast majority of battle conditions, 6pdr versus Tiger 1 = not too much use.
Things got better after (limited) intro. of APDS.
__________________
'Did it have oceans?'
'Oh yes, great wide rolling blue oceans...'
'Can't bear oceans'
mollusc is offline   Reply With Quote