I don't know mate, worth considering. This Wiki page
James Bacque - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia seems to get to the origin of the discussion and has good links to all sides of the story, along with the original article that probably began the debate:
James Bacque: Did the Allies Starve Millions of Germans?
Weird & quite unconvincing site, on a quick scan one glaring thing in the article is the bald statement/assumption that the Morgenthau plan was carried out... which it wasn't. (Why do conspiracy sites always use the same 'style'? That yellow and pink is kind of typical)
Remember these chaps clearing mines in Denmark, fascinating article, and quite refreshing after some of the sites relating to this 'controversy' I've just waded through:
Missing Links Think Tank German Mine Clearing in Denmark 1945-47