| I am so glad that you have not reacted badly to my assertions. I also apologise for the lateness of my reply.
Let's put it this way, from my converastions with Australian WW2 Pacific veterans, they thought that the Japanese were worse than scum.
However there are many comments along the lines of:
1. 'We never took prisoners'
2. 'After that we never took prisoners'
These were not idle words. They meant something.
They certainly were not 'top' organised or planned, but still very real. If a soldier surrenders, they should be treated according to the rules of war (the Geneva Convention).
My father mentions to me that my grandfather shot prisoners, I have no way of knowing this, but then again I find it quite believable.
I know of one instance when Japanese prisoners (20+) were taken in New Guinea and the air supply drop missed its mark and landed on the Japanese lines. The Japanese soldiers were then executed.
Do I feel I can morally judge these men - NO. Do I feel that it breached the Geneva Convention - YES.
Thanks,
Aaron |