Quote:
Originally Posted by Von Poop  so,
To compare Oranges with Oranges, rather than grapes with Melons.
Late model PzKw.IV, or Sherman Firefly?
(Swallow books rather good.) |
Not really. The late PzIV was at the limit of its development, overweight and overstressed - the front bogie springs became permanently bowed. Its agility and turret traverse was always inferior to the Sherman's, and in a tight melee the Shermans generally won easily. Plus the 17-pounder's performance equalled or exceeded the Panther's 75mm L/70.
I'd say the Firefly was the poor man's Panther. Or perhaps the thinking man's, in view of the man-hours and resources needed for the latter.
Regards,
MikB